Villaume & Schiek, P.A.
Call Us Today, Free consultation
Local 952-232-1886
Toll Free866-719-3452

Court of Appeals calls unemployment fraud law unconstitutional

On Monday, the Minnesota Court of Appeals struck down a law intended to prevent unemployment fraud, saying the law is based on "anecdotal evidence of a hypothetical fraud scheme," that it is arbitrary, and that it violates the Minnesota Constitution's Equal Protection Clause.

The case was reportedly brought by a Richfield man who had cared for his mother as a PCA between March 2010 and December 2011. Although DEED did not accuse him of trying to manipulate the system, it denied unemployment benefits under the law, which took effect in 2010.

The law, which was defended by the Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Redevelopment (DEED), bars unemployment benefits for personal care assistants who take care of family members.

According to DEED, the law solved a supposed fraud scheme in which PCA's caring for family members would falsify work hours to increase unemployment benefits. But the court said that DEED offered no evidence or legal authority to support the allegation of fraud.

The court did admit that existing fraud protections are inadequate to address the issue, but that the law created a presumption that any immediate family member personal care assistance who applies for unemployment is doing so out for dishonest purposes.

The decision means that county courts may no longer enforce the law, which was not properly founded in the first place.

While we don't want to stretch the comparison too far, the inadequacies of the law as cited by the appeals court are always a concern when it comes to defending those accused of fraud. Ensuring that charges are properly founded is a primary concern for defense attorneys, along with protecting the defendant's basic rights.

Source: Minneapolis Business Journal, "Unemployment fraud law rules unconstitutional by Minnesota Court of Appeals," Jim Hammerand, February 25, 2013

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Villaume & Schiek, P.A.
2051 Killebrew Drive, Suite 611
Bloomington, MN 55425

Phone: 952-232-1886
Toll Free: 866-719-3452
Fax: 952-851-9510
Bloomington Law Office Map

  • Risks & potential benefits of disclosing mental illness: Part II
    [Aug 27] Earlier this week, we began a discussion about mental illness as it relates to employment. Most employers understand and are willing to accommodate an obvious and visible disability, such as one requiring the use of a wheelchair. But mental... Read More
  • Risks & potential benefits of disclosing mental illness: Part I
    [Aug 27] It is commonly understood that individuals are at risk of suffering disability discrimination in the workplace if they have an obvious and visible disability. After all, you can't really hide the fact that you rely on a wheelchair unless... Read More
  • Minnesota trio charged with drug sales in sting
    [Aug 27] Three men were detained in Minnesota in relation to their alleged involvement in heroin sales on the morning of Aug. 20. Law enforcement executed search warrants on two apartments in the 300 block of Main Street South beginning at... Read More
  • Trial date for man accused of DWI death of Minnesota newlywed
    [Aug 26] A trial date has been set for a man charged with DWI and numerous other offenses in relation to a car accident that led to the death of a Minnesota woman during her New Hampshire honeymoon. The 2013 crash... Read More
  • False sex crime allegation tarnishes rocker's reputation
    [Aug 24] An allegation of sexual assault can have serious consequences for both the accused and the alleged victim. A recent case involving indie rocker Oberst provides context. The allegation was made on a woman’s personal website. It took a $1.2... Read More
  • Minnesota man sentenced to prison for selling synthetic drugs
    [Aug 22] A Minnesota man who was accused of selling synthetic drugs was received a 17-and-a-half-year sentence on Aug. 14. According to the report, the man was convicted on 51 charges associated with the selling of synthetic drugs known as "spice,"... Read More